IntelliJ 14.X Onwards

From version 14.0 onwards, the path to the setting dialog is slightly different, a General submenu has been added between Editor and Appearance as shown below

enter image description here

IntelliJ 8.1.2 - 13.X

From IntelliJ 8.1.2 onwards, this option is in File | Settings 1. Within the IDE Settings section of that dialog, you'll find it under Editor | Appearance.

  1. On a Mac, these are named IntelliJ IDEA | Preferences...

enter image description here